LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower Review: The Quiet Revolution for Small Lawns

There’s a certain Sunday morning ritual that many of us dread: wrestling the hulking, gas-guzzling lawn mower from the garage, the frustrating pull-start sequence, the inevitable cloud of blue smoke, and the deafening roar that shatters the neighborhood peace. For years, this was my reality. I associated lawn care with noise, fumes, and mechanical fuss. I longed for a simpler, quieter, more connected way to maintain my small patch of green. The idea of a mower that required no gas, no oil, no batteries—just a bit of human-powered effort—was incredibly appealing. It felt like a return to basics, a way to care for my yard without polluting the air or my eardrums. This search for a peaceful and effective lawn care solution is what led me to explore the world of manual reel mowers, and specifically, to get my hands on the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower.

What to Consider Before Buying a Walk-Behind Lawn Mower

A walk-behind lawn mower is more than just an item; it’s a key solution for achieving a healthy, well-manicured lawn that enhances your home’s curb appeal. The core benefit of a manual reel mower, in particular, lies in its simplicity and eco-friendliness. Unlike their gas or electric counterparts, they offer a quiet, emission-free operation that’s both good for the environment and your relationship with your neighbors. The unique scissor-like cutting action of the blades snips the grass cleanly, which is healthier for the turf than the tearing action of a rotary blade. This results in a greener, more resilient lawn over time. However, this simplicity comes with a trade-off: they are powered entirely by you, demanding a certain level of physical fitness and a commitment to regular mowing before the grass gets too tall.

The ideal customer for this type of product is someone facing the challenges of a small to medium-sized, relatively flat lawn. You value quiet operation, have environmental concerns about fossil fuels, and enjoy a bit of light physical activity. It’s perfect for the suburban homeowner with a quarter-acre plot or less who mows weekly. Conversely, a push reel mower might not be suitable for those who have very large properties, steep hills, or uneven terrain with lots of weeds, twigs, and obstacles. If you frequently let your grass grow very long between cuts, the manual action will become a significant struggle. In those cases, a powerful gas, a convenient battery-powered, or a self-propelled mower would be a much better alternative.

Before investing, consider these crucial points in detail:

• Dimensions & Space: Consider the cutting width (or deck size). The 18-inch width of the LawnMaster is a great middle-ground, wide enough to cover a small lawn efficiently without being too cumbersome to maneuver around flower beds or trees. Also, think about storage. A reel mower’s smaller, simpler frame generally takes up less space in a garage or shed compared to a bulky gas mower.
• Capacity/Performance: For a reel mower, performance is about the quality of the cut and the height options. A 5-blade system, like the one on this model, is ideal for common lawn grasses like Fescue, Ryegrass, and Bluegrass, providing a clean, sharp cut. The range of height adjustments is also critical; the LawnMaster offers nine positions from 0.75 to 2 inches, allowing you to tailor the cut to your lawn’s needs, though this range is lower than many powered mowers.
• Materials & Durability: Look for hardened, alloy steel blades, as they will hold their edge longer and resist damage. The wheels and handle construction are also important for longevity. While most of the mower is steel, be aware of plastic components in the height adjustment mechanism or wheels, as these can be potential points of failure, a concern some users have noted.
• Ease of Use & Maintenance: “Ease of use” for a reel mower translates to how easily it pushes and how simple it is to adjust. Large wheels, like the 10-inch ones on this model, help smooth out the ride over slight bumps. Maintenance is minimal compared to a gas mower—no oil changes or spark plugs—but you will need to keep the blades clean, properly adjusted, and occasionally sharpened to maintain peak cutting performance.

While the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower is an excellent choice for a specific type of user, it’s always wise to see how it stacks up against the competition. For a broader look at top models, especially if you’re considering stepping up to a powered option, we highly recommend checking out our complete, in-depth guide:

First Impressions and Unboxing the LawnMaster 18-Inch Reel Mower

Pulling the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower from its box, the first thing we noticed was its manageable weight. At just over 32 pounds (14.67 kg), it felt substantial enough to be durable but light enough for easy transport and maneuvering. Assembly was straightforward and, as advertised, largely tool-free. The pieces click and lock together, though we can see why some users described it as a “ring puzzle.” You have to assemble the handle components in the correct sequence, and a quick glance at the instructions is definitely required. We had it ready to go in about 20 minutes. The overall aesthetic is simple and functional, with a classic black finish. The padded handle grip is a nice touch, offering a bit of comfort for the job ahead. The large 10-inch front wheels give it a sturdy, capable appearance, and the height adjustment lever felt easy to operate, clicking firmly into each of its nine positions. Compared to other reel mowers we’ve tested, the build felt solid for its price point, though we immediately noted the collection bag seemed like a potential weak point—the frame is simple wire and the bag material is thin. You can see its full feature set and user reviews for a complete picture.

A Deep Dive into the LawnMaster’s Real-World Performance

Putting a mower through its paces is about more than just a single pass on a perfect lawn. It’s about understanding its strengths, weaknesses, and ideal use case. We tested the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower over several weeks on different sections of lawn—some pristine, some a bit neglected—to get a true sense of its capabilities.

The Scissor-Cut Action: A Healthier, Crisper Cut

The heart of any reel mower is its cutting mechanism, and this is where the LawnMaster truly shines under the right conditions. The five alloy steel blades spin against a stationary bedknife, creating a precise scissor-like action. We watched closely as it snipped each blade of grass cleanly, leaving a manicured, crisp finish that you just don’t get from a rotary mower. Rotary mowers use a single, high-speed blade that essentially rips and tears the tops of the grass, which can lead to browning, stress, and increased susceptibility to disease. The clean cut from the LawnMaster promotes faster healing and healthier growth, resulting in a visibly greener lawn.

We found this to be absolutely true on our well-maintained front lawn, which we keep at about 1.5 inches. The mower glided through, leaving satisfyingly neat rows. However, this beautiful cut is entirely conditional. As confirmed by numerous user reports, if the grass is too long or thick, the story changes. When we moved to a patch we’d let grow for ten days, the mower began to bog down, and instead of cutting, it would sometimes push the taller grass over. This isn’t a flaw of this specific model, but rather a characteristic of all manual reel mowers: they are tools for maintenance, not for reclamation projects. For anyone dedicated to a weekly mowing schedule, the cut quality is a feature that really sets it apart.

Adjustability and Control: Dialing in the Perfect Height

Lawn health is heavily dependent on cutting height, and the LawnMaster offers a surprising amount of control for a manual mower. The single-lever system provides nine distinct cutting positions, ranging from a very low 0.75 inches up to 2 inches. This range is fantastic for homeowners who want to achieve that short, carpet-like look on their lawn. We tested the adjustment mechanism repeatedly; it was easy to use and locked securely into place each time. There was no fumbling with four individual wheel adjusters, which is a huge plus.

However, we must echo a sentiment found in user feedback: even the highest setting of 2 inches is quite low compared to powered mowers that can go up to 4 inches or more. If you prefer a taller, lusher lawn, this mower’s range might feel restrictive. During our test, we started at the highest setting and found it gave a very neat, but decidedly short, “buzz cut” look. For many, this is the desired outcome. The 18-inch cutting width combined with the 10-inch wheels provided excellent maneuverability. We guided it around our mailbox, garden beds, and along the edge of the driveway with minimal effort. It turns on a dime and is light enough to pick up and reposition if you get into a tight corner.

The Manual Experience: You Are the Motor

This is the defining aspect of using the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower. There is no engine to start, no battery to charge. The only sounds are the gentle snip-snip-snip of the blades and the whirring of the wheels. It’s a remarkably peaceful experience. You can mow in the early morning or late evening without disturbing anyone. We found it to be a pleasant, low-impact workout, as one user aptly described it, “good calorie burning fun!” Pushing it across a flat, maintained 20×20 foot area was easy and almost effortless.

That said, your energy is the fuel. When we encountered a slight incline or a patch of thicker grass, the required effort increased noticeably. We also confirmed that twigs, small rocks, or even thick weed stems can jam the reel, forcing you to stop and clear the obstruction. This is an unavoidable part of the reel mower experience. The included collection bag proved to be a source of frustration. It’s small, filling up very quickly, and its simple hook design means it can detach easily, spilling clippings. After a few passes, we opted to leave it off entirely and either rake the clippings or let them mulch back into the lawn. For the right person with a small, simple yard, the manual experience is a rewarding ritual. If you want to check the latest price and availability, it represents an incredible value for this type of lawn care.

Assembly and Long-Term Durability: A Mixed Bag

Our assembly experience was positive and took under 20 minutes without any tools. The instructions were clear enough to follow. However, we did pay close attention, as it’s easy to see how one could misalign the handle sections. We can’t ignore the significant number of user reports flagging quality control and durability issues. While our test unit performed flawlessly, complaints about missing screws, units arriving scratched, or, more seriously, the height adjustment spokes breaking after only a few uses, are cause for concern. This suggests some inconsistency in manufacturing. The alloy steel blades themselves feel robust and capable of holding an edge, but potential weaknesses in plastic components of the adjustment system or wheel assemblies could limit the mower’s lifespan. We recommend a thorough inspection upon arrival and caution against overly aggressive handling, especially when navigating rough patches that could put stress on the frame and adjustment mechanism.

What Other Users Are Saying

Sifting through feedback from other owners provides a well-rounded and honest perspective that largely mirrors our own findings. There is a clear divide in user experience that hinges almost entirely on lawn size and condition. On one side, users with small, flat yards are ecstatic. One person noted, “I can’t begin to express how much this product has changed my family’s life!” praising its lightweight, efficient, and eco-friendly nature. Another was “impressed with the quality of the cut on my lawn! Got the lawn looking as crisp as a gas mower would!” These users understood the product’s intended purpose and were rewarded with excellent results.

On the other hand, the negative feedback is equally telling. The most common complaint is the mower’s inability to handle tall grass. “If you let the grass get any length to it at all then it cuts horribly,” one user stated bluntly. Others pointed to serious durability issues, like the owner who said the “level spokes broke” after just 4-5 uses, rendering it useless. Reports of the machine jamming constantly or the grass catcher being a “joke” are also prevalent. This feedback is critical: the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower is a specialized tool, not a one-size-fits-all solution, and its performance is highly dependent on proper use and realistic expectations.

How the LawnMaster Compares to the Alternatives

While the LawnMaster holds its own in the manual mower space, it’s important to see how it stacks up against other options, both within its category and for those considering a different power source.

1. Scotts 14-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Lawn Mower

The Scotts 14-Inch mower is a direct competitor and a classic in the reel mower world. The most significant difference is the cutting width: at 14 inches, it’s four inches narrower than the LawnMaster. This makes the Scotts model even more maneuverable in very tight spaces or for lawns with intricate landscaping and many obstacles. However, that narrower path means you’ll be taking more passes to cover the same area. For someone with a tiny yard, a small townhouse lawn, or just narrow strips of grass, the Scotts mower might be a more nimble choice. For most small-but-open lawns, the LawnMaster’s 18-inch deck offers a better balance of coverage and maneuverability.

2. Greenworks 40V 20″ Brushless Push Mower 4.0Ah

For those who love the idea of eco-friendly mowing but aren’t sold on the physical workout, the Greenworks 40V is the logical next step. This is a battery-powered push mower, meaning the blade is powered, but you still provide the forward momentum. It completely solves the reel mower’s biggest problem: tall or thick grass. The brushless motor and 20-inch steel deck can power through tough conditions that would instantly jam the LawnMaster. It offers a much higher cutting range and bags clippings far more effectively. The trade-off is a higher initial cost, the need to manage and charge batteries, and a significantly heavier machine.

3. Greenworks 48V Lawn Mower Trimmer Blower Combo

This Greenworks combo kit represents the premium, all-in-one solution for yard care. It’s for the homeowner who is ready to ditch gas entirely and invest in a complete battery-powered ecosystem. The mower is not only powered but also self-propelled, taking all the effort out of pushing. With a wider 21-inch deck, it’s built for medium-to-large lawns. The inclusion of a string trimmer and a leaf blower means you have every major tool you need, all running on the same battery platform. This is a world away from the simplicity of the LawnMaster; it’s a choice for someone prioritizing power, convenience, and features over the minimalist, manual approach.

The Final Verdict: Is the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower for You?

After extensive testing and analysis, our verdict on the LawnMaster 18-Inch 5-Blade Push Reel Mower is clear: it is an excellent tool for the right job. If you have a small, mostly flat lawn (think a quarter-acre or less) and are committed to mowing it regularly (at least once a week), this mower can deliver a beautiful, healthy, and satisfyingly quiet cut. Its eco-friendly, zero-emission operation is a massive benefit for both the environment and your ears. It is lightweight, easy to store, and requires virtually no maintenance beyond basic cleaning and blade care.

However, it is not a tool for everyone. If your yard is large, hilly, bumpy, or if you’re the type to let the lawn get overgrown between mowings, you will be met with frustration. The potential for jamming on twigs and the reported durability concerns with some components are real drawbacks to consider. Ultimately, this mower is for the lawn care traditionalist, the eco-conscious homeowner, and the person who finds a certain zen in the simple, quiet work of maintaining their own green space. If that sounds like you, the LawnMaster offers incredible value. For those ready to embrace a simpler way to a perfect lawn, we highly recommend you find out more and check the current price today.